All Categories› Poker Chat

You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

A question on a rule?

GavinxxxxGavinxxxx Member Posts: 559
edited September 2010 in Poker Chat
Ok heres the situation

A £10 rebuy tournament at my local Casino

Self dealers
3 people in the hand

The dealer deals the flop
4 3 5
1st position - bets 300
2nd position - calls

The dealer then deals the turn (missed 3rd position) (turn card was a QUEEN OF SPADES)

After a discusion around the  table the dealer puts the queen of spades back into the deck and reshuffles, everybody happy now ? no, position one says the rule is that the card should stay on the turn.

After a while a ruler is called.

What do you think happened ?

It made me chuckle lol







· Share on Twitter

Comments

  • SHANXTASHANXTA Member Posts: 1,507
    edited September 2010
    what happened is correct
    · Share on Twitter
  • batman4batman4 Member Posts: 188
    edited September 2010
    3rd positions hand is mucked--

    the cards should never be shuffled in the middle of the hand--

    deal becomes dead and void at that stage--

    then split pot between players 1 and 2--

    start new hand--


    simple--
    not at this game--
    anything could have been ruled--
    · Share on Twitter
  • SHANXTASHANXTA Member Posts: 1,507
    edited September 2010
    In Response to Re: A question on a rule?:
    3rd positions hand is mucked-- the cards should never be shuffled in the middle of the hand-- deal becomes dead and void at that stage-- then split pot between players 1 and 2-- start new hand-- simple-- not at this game-- anything could have been ruled--
    Posted by batman4
    what happened (the Q being returned and the pack re-shuffled and the turn re-dealt) is pretty standard at most casino's now
    · Share on Twitter
  • GavinxxxxGavinxxxx Member Posts: 559
    edited September 2010
    Well anyway this is what happened,

    position 1 is really moaning saying the queen should of stood, making it obvious that the queen made his hand, and when the ruler came he said, that putting the card back into the deck and reshuffle and then deal the turn again is the rule.

    Well position 1 was not happy, huffing and puffing.

    So dealer puts the queen of spades back into deck, shuffles, deals the turn.....
    .....
    ........
    ............
    ..............
    QUEEN OF SPADES !!! whats the odds lol

    anyway cut a long story short the position 1 guy had 2 pair and position 3 player flopped the straight LOL.
    · Share on Twitter
  • The_Don90The_Don90 Member Posts: 9,814
    edited September 2010
    What happened is the correct ruling. Batman im not sure what rules your following my old league followed the same rules but i can assure you this casinos way is correct.

    Posistion 3s hand is not mucked.

    Im sure this has been discussed here before and 3 different rules came out, i since done reasearch with the rules i follow and it is correct to return and re-shuffle.
    · Share on Twitter
  • batman4batman4 Member Posts: 188
    edited September 2010
    In Response to Re: A question on a rule?:
    What happened is the correct ruling. Batman im not sure what rules your following my old league followed the same rules but i can assure you this casinos way is correct. Posistion 3s hand is not mucked. Im sure this has been discussed here before and 3 different rules came out, i since done reasearch with the rules i follow and it is correct to return and re-shuffle.
    Posted by The_Don90
    to be honest i hadn't a clue--  :))

    · Share on Twitter
Sign In or Register to comment.