All Categories› Poker Chat

You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

is this correct?

longman912longman912 Member Posts: 89
edited May 2011 in Poker Chat
playing live down the pub i had pocket 8s and picked up a set on the flop. by the river i had quad 8s and my opponent obviously had a straight. i put him all in. he turned to me and said have you got the 8 to which i replied no i have a pair of them thinking he wouldnt believe me, he didnt and called. later i was told that in a casino it is not permmitted to tell truth about your hole cards is this correct?
· Share on Twitter

Comments

  • spornybolspornybol Member Posts: 8,212
    edited May 2011
    you really should say not even if you are telling truth, let them work it out
    · Share on Twitter
  • longman912longman912 Member Posts: 89
    edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: is this correct?:
    you really should say not even if you are telling truth, let them work it out
    Posted by spornybol
    i know the guy well and was fairly sure he was calling anyway so i said it as a sort of double bluff.
    · Share on Twitter
  • GEO68GEO68 Member Posts: 281
    edited May 2011
    He asked a question you gave an answer , up to him how he chooses to use that information.
    · Share on Twitter
  • acebarry10acebarry10 Member Posts: 7,556
    edited May 2011
    In Response to is this correct?:
    playing live down the pub i had pocket 8s and picked up a set on the flop. by the river i had quad 8s and my opponent obviously had a straight. i put him all in. he turned to me and said have you got the 8 to which i replied no i have a pair of them thinking he wouldnt believe me, he didnt and called. later i was told that in a casino it is not permmitted to tell truth about your hole cards is this correct?
    Posted by longman912
    Hi longman

    This may help: Do not reveal your cards while a hand is going on. While it's not against the rules (some places may give a penalty), it is at least a horrible breach of etiquette.
    · Share on Twitter
  • igimcigimc Member Posts: 625
    edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: is this correct?:
    In Response to is this correct? : Hi longman This may help: Do not reveal your cards while a hand is going on. While it's not against the rules (some places may give a penalty), it is at least a horrible breach of etiquette.
    Posted by acebarry10
    Why??
    the other guy engaged the conversation by asking him what he had.He should be able to tell
    him anything he wants to IMO.
    I don't get this breach of etiquette malarky at all
    · Share on Twitter
  • AMYBRAMYBR Member Posts: 3,432
    edited May 2011
    Official Tournament poker ruling.  If your asked about your hand in a multiway pot and tell the truth, your hand is dead.

    Cash game fine.

    HU in Tournament, normally allowed.

    But as a rule just dont do it.

    · Share on Twitter
  • LOL_RAISELOL_RAISE Member Posts: 2,188
    edited May 2011
    what amybr said
    · Share on Twitter
  • Tikay10Tikay10 Member, Administrator, Moderator Posts: 174,097
    edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: is this correct?:
    In Response to Re: is this correct? : Why?? the other guy engaged the conversation by asking him what he had.He should be able to tell him anything he wants to IMO. I don't get this breach of etiquette malarky at all
    Posted by igimc
    It was NOT a breach of etiquette - it was a breach of the standard rules of poker.

    Put simply, you can NOT tell your opponent "anything you wish".

    Them's the Rules, whether we like them or not is immaterial. As a rule......
    · Share on Twitter
  • bandinibandini Member Posts: 1,802
    edited May 2011
    In Response to Re: is this correct?:
    In Response to Re: is this correct? : It was NOT a breach of etiquette - it was a breach of the standard rules of poker. Put simply, you can NOT tell your opponent "anything you wish". Them's the Rules, whether we like them or not is immaterial. As a rule......
    Posted by Tikay10
    Yip, saying your exact hand is a no-no.

    But I don't understand why. Doesn't make sense to me. If some-one engages you in speech play then surely between the players involved it's between them?

    I just don't do speech play when playing live because it's a minefield. Cover my mouth (that's where the tells are, invent shades for the mouth and I'm buying them) and stare at a blank spot in the table.

    And are there actual rules written anywhere or has it just evolved? Because I've had TD's making rulings that I haven't agreed with at times.

    Got accused of string betting after I'd said all-in once. It seemd like there was some prize going for accusing anyone of string betting. I've only got 2 f hands, I can't put all the chips in at once. Freaked a bit. And I'm a fairly mild mannered, placid, Ghandi type of chap, I really am.
    · Share on Twitter
Sign In or Register to comment.