You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN

GREGA1GREGA1 Member Posts: 4
edited November 2009 in Poker Chat
TWICE IN THE LAST TWO WEEKS PLAYERS ACTING OUT OF TURN HAS COST ME BIG TIME.THE FIRST TIME A PLAYER IN THE CUT OFF CHECKS,ON THE RIVER, I AM IN THE BIG BLIND WITH NOTHING BUT BELIEVE I CAN GET 1 OTHER OPPONENT IN THE HAND TO PASS.I THEN GO ALL IN, PLAYER 2 FOLDS AND THE GUY IN THE CUT OFF CALLS AND SHOWS THE NUTS.I WOULD NOT HAVE DONE THIS WITHOUT THE DODGY CHECK.I BELIEVE THIS IS CHEATING BUT IN THE RULES IT SAYS PLAYING OUT OF TURN IS WRONG BUT THERE IS NO PENALTY. THE SECOND TIME I AM AGAIN IN THE BIG BLIND AND FACE A MIN RAISE FROM 1 OPPONENT.I CALL.I FLOP AN OPEN ENDER BUT EVEN BEFORE THE FLOP IS DEALT THE RAISER ANNOUNCES ALL IN.I KNOW THEN HE HAS GOT AA AND DONT WISH TO CALL.HAD HE NOT DONE THIS I WOULD HAVE PUSHED ALL IN MYSELF AND PUT THE DECISION ON HIM.AGAIN I FEEL THIS IS CHEATING.I LOOK FORWARD TO READING ALL YOUR VIEWS.

Comments

  • scotty77scotty77 Member Posts: 4,970
    edited November 2009
    I have no idea what you're on about.  How can you act out of turn online.  How can the CO check before you.  It doesn't make any sense.

    Oh okay if you are on about live poker then this is known as angle shooting, and you should always think twice before you make any action as some players are slimey slimey people and use it as a way to induce these kind of bets.
  • FBSFBS Member Posts: 131
    edited November 2009


    In the club I play at any out of turn play brings an enforced check ( or call ) so in the 2nd situation above you could have checked and that would have forced the other player to check giving you a free card to hit your open ender ....

    not much you can do about the first situation though ... live play sucks some times when folks pull stunts like that.
  • GREGA1GREGA1 Member Posts: 4
    edited November 2009
    SCOTTY 77 THEY WERE BOTH IN LIVE GAMES AND I BELIEVE SLIMEY PLAY IS CHEATING.
    THANX FOR UR VIEW FBS IN THE SECOND INSTANCE THATS WHAT I THOUGHT BUT THE CARDROOM MANAGER SAID THE ALL IN BET HAD TO STAND.
  • FlashFlushFlashFlush Member Posts: 4,494
    edited November 2009
    I play at a local poker club with some very good players.. One of them in once tournament was 2nd to act after the flop... but while the 1st to act was counting chips to bet, he calls all in... player1 then takes the chips back and says, ok ill check... player2 then says i check (to everyones suprise) on turn player 1 checks again, player 2 THEN says all in.... player1 folds and player2 shows absolute air... he then said "how else was i going to make you fold?" that was a bit harsh IMO and an obvious bit of 'side shooting'... o well you learn these things with age i suppose
  • Tikay10Tikay10 Member, Administrator, Moderator Posts: 169,649
    edited November 2009
    In Response to DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    TWICE IN THE LAST TWO WEEKS PLAYERS ACTING OUT OF TURN HAS COST ME BIG TIME.THE FIRST TIME A PLAYER IN THE CUT OFF CHECKS,ON THE RIVER, I AM IN THE BIG BLIND WITH NOTHING BUT BELIEVE I CAN GET 1 OTHER OPPONENT IN THE HAND TO PASS.I THEN GO ALL IN, PLAYER 2 FOLDS AND THE GUY IN THE CUT OFF CALLS AND SHOWS THE NUTS.I WOULD NOT HAVE DONE THIS WITHOUT THE DODGY CHECK.I BELIEVE THIS IS CHEATING BUT IN THE RULES IT SAYS PLAYING OUT OF TURN IS WRONG BUT THERE IS NO PENALTY. THE SECOND TIME I AM AGAIN IN THE BIG BLIND AND FACE A MIN RAISE FROM 1 OPPONENT.I CALL.I FLOP AN OPEN ENDER BUT EVEN BEFORE THE FLOP IS DEALT THE RAISER ANNOUNCES ALL IN.I KNOW THEN HE HAS GOT AA AND DONT WISH TO CALL.HAD HE NOT DONE THIS I WOULD HAVE PUSHED ALL IN MYSELF AND PUT THE DECISION ON HIM.AGAIN I FEEL THIS IS CHEATING.I LOOK FORWARD TO READING ALL YOUR VIEWS.
    Posted by GREGA1
    Yes, if we omit the fancy words - "angle-shooting" etc - this is cheating.

    In a well-run Cardroom, the Player would face a Penalty for the first offence, & disqualification for a 2nd offence, but there are only two Venues in the UK that would actually impose that - most Venues are nowhere near strict enough.

    It's one of the drawbacks of Live Poker - we don't have uniform rules, anywhere in the world, & the Rules we do have are not consistently applied.

    Correcting this is one of the fundamental principles of APAT, of which I'm proud to be (unpaid) Chairman, & over the last 4 years, the Team at APAT have taken great strides in correcting this ridiculous situation, but it takes time.

    Online, we never have these problems of course. Those who decry Online Poker forget this - when you play Online, the Rules are set in stone. And, of course, you cannot act out of turn!
  • Tikay10Tikay10 Member, Administrator, Moderator Posts: 169,649
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    I play at a local poker club with some very good players.. One of them in once tournament was 2nd to act after the flop... but while the 1st to act was counting chips to bet, he calls all in... player1 then takes the chips back and says, ok ill check... player2 then says i check (to everyones suprise) on turn player 1 checks again, player 2 THEN says all in.... player1 folds and player2 shows absolute air... he then said "how else was i going to make you fold?" that was a bit harsh IMO and an obvious bit of 'side shooting'... o well you learn these things with age i suppose
    Posted by FlashFlush
    Lol at the Player taking his chips back, flouting just about every rule in Poker! When his Chips go in, they must stay in. End of!
  • Tikay10Tikay10 Member, Administrator, Moderator Posts: 169,649
    edited November 2009

    Mods - this Thread belongs in General Poker Chat.

    This could never happen on the Sky Poker Tour, which is run to MUCH higher standards than this!
  • FlashFlushFlashFlush Member Posts: 4,494
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN : Lol at the Player taking his chips back, flouting just about every rule in Poker! When his Chips go in, they must stay in. End of!
    Posted by Tikay10
     They were not actually across the line at this point.. he had counted then taken them off his stack and was just about to put them over the line when player2 calls all in, purposly just in time before the bet actually counted
  • zxghostxzzxghostxz Member Posts: 482
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    SCOTTY 77 THEY WERE BOTH IN LIVE GAMES AND I BELIEVE SLIMEY PLAY IS CHEATING. THANX FOR UR VIEW FBS IN THE SECOND INSTANCE THATS WHAT I THOUGHT BUT THE CARDROOM MANAGER SAID THE ALL IN BET HAD TO STAND.
    Posted by GREGA1
    you got sukkerd   mate.  wat u should av done is waited outside the casino for him and sukkerd him.  lol .you would be feelin a lot better now.....
  • themackemthemackem Member Posts: 195
    edited November 2009
    ive played many a live tourney where people play out of turnh or walk away after hand is dealt to go make a loo stop or phone call well before their turn to act...

    75% of the time its an accidental fold out of turn.....  you cannot disqualify these people ........
  • FlashFlushFlashFlush Member Posts: 4,494
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    ive played many a live tourney where people play out of turnh or walk away after hand is dealt to go make a loo stop or phone call well before their turn to act... 75% of the time its an accidental fold out of turn.....  you cannot disqualify these people ........
    Posted by themackem
     No if it is a genuine accident thats easily spotted... But we are talking about people who "Angle-Shoot" like the person I spoke about... They do this on purpose to win the pot. We have changed the rules at the club now, if he says all in out of turn he HAS to go all in now.

     Another example of him doing it, we had our yearly £3,000 FR and all river had been dealt... He bets out on the river and the other player is thinkingfor ages... as soon as the player thinking made any movement, he said "Two" then stopped... as if to say 2 pair... the player thinking then folds and the "angle shooter" laughs and says ha ha i had nothing, how else was i going to make you fold? NOW THAT IS NOT AN ACCIDENT AND SHOULD BE A DQ/WARNING
  • themackemthemackem Member Posts: 195
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN :  No if it is a genuine accident thats easily spotted... But we are talking about people who "Angle-Shoot" like the person I spoke about... They do this on purpose to win the pot. We have changed the rules at the club now, if he says all in out of turn he HAS to go all in now.  Another example of him doing it, we had our yearly £3,000 FR and all river had been dealt... He bets out on the river and the other player is thinkingfor ages... as soon as the player thinking made any movement, he said "Two" then stopped... as if to say 2 pair... the player thinking then folds and the "angle shooter" laughs and says ha ha i had nothing, how else was i going to make you fold? NOW THAT IS NOT AN ACCIDENT AND SHOULD BE A DQ/WARNING
    Posted by FlashFlush
    u sure he had nothing ???
  • FlashFlushFlashFlush Member Posts: 4,494
    edited November 2009
    Yeh he showed
  • Tikay10Tikay10 Member, Administrator, Moderator Posts: 169,649
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    ive played many a live tourney where people play out of turnh or walk away after hand is dealt to go make a loo stop or phone call well before their turn to act... 75% of the time its an accidental fold out of turn.....  you cannot disqualify these people ........
    Posted by themackem
    You can penalise them, & they should be Penalised - it's the only way they learn.

    It's not always intentional to drive at 34mph in a 30, but it's still illegal, & ignorance or "accidental" is no excuse.

    Acting out of turn affects the play far more than many players (usually inexperienced) realise. Online Players cannot do it Online, & do not realise that in Live Poker, it's against every set of Poker Rules ever written.

    They should be Penalised on a Time or Orbit basis, on a totting up system. 1 Orbit first offence, 3 orbits 2nd Offence, Disqualified 3rd offence. They'd soon learn then.

    If it were up to me, I'd have them shot on the spot. *

    * Assume a smiley there please. I'm only half serious. **

    ** I'm only half-joking, too. There too much cheating & rule-bending in the game.
  • Grimstar30Grimstar30 Member Posts: 1,400
    edited November 2009
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN:
    In Response to Re: DISQUALIFY DELIBERATE PLAY OUT OF TURN : You can penalise them, & they should be Penalised - it's the only way they learn. It's not always intentional to drive at 34mph in a 30, but it's still illegal, & ignorance or "accidental" is no excuse. Acting out of turn affects the play far more than many players (usually inexperienced) realise. Online Players cannot do it Online, & do not realise that in Live Poker, it's against every set of Poker Rules ever written. They should be Penalised on a Time or Orbit basis, on a totting up system. 1 Orbit first offence, 3 orbits 2nd Offence, Disqualified 3rd offence. They'd soon learn then. If it were up to me, I'd have them shot on the spot. * * Assume a smiley there please. I'm only half serious. ** ** I'm only half-joking, too. There too much cheating & rule-bending in the game.
    Posted by Tikay10
    Yes this is called Strict Liability. 

    This should be applied to live poker. A cynical player can not hide behind the veil of Ignorance or drunkenness and there should always be a penalty of some kind for breaking the rules. As you said, start it at a low level and then be more severe.

    Dave
  • scrumdownscrumdown Member Posts: 1,609
    edited November 2009
    u  cant  play  out  of  turn  online    m8
  • EyemanEyeman Member Posts: 1,039
    edited November 2009
    Interesting point - at the last SPT event at DTD I was in a sit n go. Nutter's dad was also at the table. ANyway, about econd hand I get dealt AA. Another player goes all in, and I call him and show my AA. At this point, and to my immense embarassment, Nutter's dad announces that he hasn't folded yet. He's seen my AA, but I feel like an absolute beginner (which I am - live).
    Anyway, he folds face up QQ.
    My opponant has 55, and I double up.
    The punchline? Nutter's dad would have hit quads.
    In the end he knocked me out anyway (with an awful call, but that's what i get for bluffing).
  • EDKENT123EDKENT123 Member Posts: 416
    edited November 2009
    tikay what is APAT????????
  • EDKENT123EDKENT123 Member Posts: 416
    edited November 2009
    no worrys tikay just googled it, didnt know anything like that existed....
Sign In or Register to comment.