Recieved some rather 'tilted' comments here but here are my thoughts at the time. What's your judgem

profman15

Hi folks
Don't spare the rod by all means but say it in a constructive way please. cheers...
 I'd joined the table 3 orbits ago and not been in many hands at all hough one did double up+ my stack(im also going to put that one on another time).
My thoughts at the time with m />20 was to raise. My opponent with m=5 rerd all-in. I saw this as him being in the range of raise all-in /fold. I had a top 20% calling hand according to charts, had him covered and felt he could easily have sc, kq etc and that i may even be ahead already. If i losti'd still have a stack that could do damage.
 Was my logic flawed?
I had A3 suited. I just felt he was unlucky but my thoughts were creditable. If not i'll learn. Ta for the help.
Small blind 300.00300.0010730.00chrisg6912Big blind 600.00900.004483.14 Your hole cardsA3   Jimbob30Fold    elderFold    profman15Raise 1200.002100.0017608.75chico1740Fold    chrisg6912All-in 4483.146583.140.00profman15Call 3883.1410466.2813725.61chrisg6912ShowJJ   profman15ShowA3   Flop  Q93   Turn  4   River  3   profman15WinThree 3s10466.28 24191.89

Dudeskin8

Looks fine against short stack.

In these spots as long as you know you're calling the all in it's fine, if you raise/folded that would be MUCH worse.

Against most hands you have at least 30% and with him being uber short he can't complain at all. 

Lambert180

Yeah looks fine against a shortstack like Dude said. Can't see the stacks properly from your post but I'll take your word for it so it seems fine to me, you are right that there are plenty of hands he will be shoving where you're ahead and plenty where you aint that far behind.

grantorino

nh