You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

Should trans Women be banned from womens sports?

1235»

Comments

  • EssexphilEssexphil Member Posts: 8,989
    edited February 19
    A particularly sad and nasty story. Where absolutely no-one comes out of it with any credit-except, possibly, the child.

    Firstly, important to provide a bit of context here. This is the "Maine State Class B Championship". That would be in Maine-1 of the smallest states-population 1.4 million. Class B-so not the best athletic schools, who we can safely assume are in Class A.

    Then we have the frankly astonishingly 2-faced statement that schools should not be "prioritizing politics". Says the Republican Congresswoman Laurel Libby, who is perfectly happy to broadcast the name and picture of a vulnerable child to the World to further her own (and the Donald's) agenda.

    Next, night be worthwhile having a quick peek at the career of Mrs Libby

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurel_Libby

    Main highlights? Fervent anti-vaxxer. Refused to wear a mask when obligated to do so in State parliamentary proceedings, and gave evidence that 1 of her children had been adversely affected by a vaccine, but she had not sought any medical help. Just in case you think that is reasonable, her previous career was as an ICU Nurse

    Standing up for the rights of American Na zis both to publicly protest, and to wave loaded guns while doing so

    Then I would point you to 1 key phrase. This child is not just choosing to call themselves something different. They are in the process of "transitioning". As an example, their arm definition seems to have changed a great deal. There are no "safety" concerns in pole vault. And, frankly, no girl has ever thought placing 1st in a tiny State's "B" championships was key.

    Was it wise for this School to have entered her into this competition? I don't know all the facts, but it seems likely not. The School appears to have been just as guilty of playing politics with some poor kids life. Because they must have known the cameras were there. As for the rival school? What a vile thing to do.
  • HAYSIEHAYSIE Member Posts: 37,470
    lucy4 said:

    Boy Wins Girls’ Pole Vault Championship In Maine Days After State Pledged To Defy Trump Order.

    A transgender-identifying boy took first place in women’s pole vaulting at Maine’s Class B state championship on Monday, days after the state declared it would not enforce President Trump’s executive order banning males from female sports at public schools.

    The victory by a boy in the female event helped Greely High School girls’ track and field team clinch the championship by one point. The same student, who now goes by a girl’s name, participated under a different name as a boy just years earlier, prompting outrage from a local lawmaker who wants the administration to investigate.

    Maine state lawmaker Lauren Libby drew attention to the controversy on Monday, writing on Facebook, “Two years ago, [boy’s name] tied for 5th place in boys pole vault. Tonight, ‘[girl’s name]’ won 1st place in the girls’ Maine State Class B Championship.”



    Libby told The Daily Wire that the Trump administration should step in to protect the female athletes. Trump’s orders indicate that the administration would investigate schools that do not adhere to gender rules, and could possibly lose funding.

    “The decision by the Maine Principals’ Association to continue allowing male athletes to compete against female athletes in school athletic competitions is outrageous,” Libby said. “Not only does their decision violate President Trump’s February 5 Executive Order but it jeopardizes the safety and privacy of female athletes, all while allowing male athletes to take medals, trophies, and podium spots away from women, effectively erasing them.”

    “I urge the Trump Administration to move swiftly to ensure that female athletes in Maine can once again compete on a level playing field, preserving the integrity of women’s sports,” the statement added.

    In January, Maine’s Department of Education said it would not comply with Trump order’s on gender. Additionally, the Maine Principals’ Association (MPA) said earlier this month that the state will allow males to continue competing in girls and women’s sports, again ignoring Trump’s order to protect female sports.

    The Maine Wire reported earlier this month on the state’s decision to defy Trump’s orders on gender. Citing a concerned coach named Allen Cornwall, the report indicted that a pole vaulter on the girls’ Greely High School team is a male.

    “They’re going to be the conference champion, quote unquote girls’ conference champion,” Cornwall said of the male athlete. “They’ll be the quote unquote girls state champion for the class B athlete. And these girls that have been competing for years, working towards this, are just being sidelined, and it’s really disgusting.”

    Cornwall said the student athlete “competed in the boys’ pole vault competition for two years, where he was a mid-range athlete achieving around 12 feet, a moderate height for males,” the report said. “Since transitioning and competing against female students, he has dominated and currently ranks among the top ten girls in pole vaulting.”

    Alleigh Marré, the executive director of American Parents Coalition, ripped the MPA’s decision to allow males in girls’ sports in a statement sent to The Daily Wire.

    “Parents across Maine—and the country—are fed up with being ignored while their daughters are forced to compete against biological males,” Marré said. “The Maine Principals’ Association’s decision isn’t just unfair; it’s an affront to every parent who expects their child to have a level playing field and is at odds with President Trump’s Executive Order protecting girls’ sports. Schools should be working alongside the Administration and supporting parents, not prioritizing politics.”

    “The American Parents Coalition applauds Rep. Laurel Libby for standing up for female athletes and bringing attention to this issue,” the statement added.

    The Independent Council on Women’s Sports (ICONS), an advocacy organization working to protect female sports, posted about the competition as well.

    “Maine awards the girls’ state pole vault title to a male athlete competing in the girls’ division,” it said in a post on X. “Greely High School’s male star vaulter … not only won the event but also helped secure his girls’ team the overall state championship by just one point.”

    The Daily Wire reached out to district’s superintendent and athletic director about the competition and Greely’s policy on males in female athletics. Neither responded to requests for comment.

    https://www.dailywire.com/news/boy-wins-girls-pole-vault-championship-in-maine-days-after-state-pledged-to-defy-trump-order

    If I was still here I would be resting my case about now.
Sign In or Register to comment.