You need to be logged in to your Sky Poker account above to post discussions and comments.

You might need to refresh your page afterwards.

Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post

simuksimuk Member Posts: 315
edited March 2011 in Poker Chat
Hey guys, 

Check out my latest blog post and send in your thoughts. 

Sim
«134

Comments

  • mavgun1mavgun1 Member Posts: 1
    edited February 2011
    Only when I lose!!!!
  • JIMMYMADJIMMYMAD Member Posts: 154
    edited February 2011
    Just red it Sim good read, agree entirely on the last paragraph  
  • bandinibandini Member Posts: 1,802
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    Hey guys,  Check out my latest blog post and send in your thoughts.  Sim
    Posted by simuk
    Generally, I'd say no.

    Seeing how good you run though I ask myself questions, lol. How much you paying Giddens?

    Will read blog.
  • JockBMWJockBMW Member Posts: 2,653
    edited February 2011
    Nice Blog SIm.

    This thread should get the conspiracy theorists out in droves.

    Excellent ;o)

    By the way am I paranoid, if everyone REALLY is out to get me ?
  • scouse_redscouse_red Member Posts: 5,968
    edited February 2011
    read your blog last night m8

    at last someone who uses / speaks common sense. Great read
  • MachkaMachka Member Posts: 4,627
    edited February 2011
    Blog is here, great read.
  • pod1pod1 Member Posts: 4,377
    edited February 2011
    dont let elsa read it or irish for that matter. good read mind  phil
  • stienstien Member Posts: 332
    edited February 2011

     I posted this on the blog but I didn't want to deprive those who have already read sims piece the opportunity to answer this question.

    The real issue is that too many people believe RNG's are rigged and won't play on-line any more, I know plenty. It is for the poker industry to prove beyond any doubt that the RNG's are right, surely it is in their best interests to do this, don't they want these doubters back? It strikes me as a little odd that nothing has been done to seriously address this issue, particularly now, when traffic volumes are falling on many sites. Here's our bit of paper from a company no ones ever heard of isn't enough to bring the doubters back, if they were authenticated by a well know reputable company that would be a start, how about Deloitte's or KPMG.

  • elsadogelsadog Member Posts: 5,677
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Re: Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    dont let elsa read it or irish for that matter. good read mind  phil
    Posted by pod1
    I've read it and it's a well put together argument from a much respected player. I would give it more credibility if the Alderney GCC would give a straight answer to questions about the deal, and if Sky Bernie would give any answers at all to the perfectly legitimate questions he was asked. Any reply at all from the RNG certifiers would be good too - they seem to have ''gone away''

    Until then I will have my doubts.


  • Kiwini4uKiwini4u Member Posts: 3,830
    edited February 2011
    Excellent blog Sim, and I agree with everything that you say.
  • elsadogelsadog Member Posts: 5,677
    edited February 2011
    I wonder if this will get shunted to area 51 - somehow I doubt it :o)
  • AMYBRAMYBR Member Posts: 3,432
    edited February 2011
    I've got to be honest I find the blog shortsighted and very narrow-minded.  I hear the points raised and have spent much time pondering them myself.  I make a pretty decent living at Live Poker, mainly playing in the North East Casino's and DTD.  But Online I have had the utter worst swings.  I'm not a believer in the higher hand rate more bad beats scenarios.  Any player worth their salt does alot of hand analysis away from the table.  Where this industry comment seems to hold truth, when its picked apart it doesnt.  The counter-argument that we harbour our badbeats far longer than our more frequent - balancing - wins doesnt cover it either, to my mind. 

    I don't say online poker is rigged.  But I do say that there is something very erroneous about RNG's. 

    I hear the points clearly.  I for one HAVE decided to play very little online, as per the last paragraph of the blog.  But I do feel that that last paragraph is unfair to individuals that percieve something to be wrong.  As consumers they retain the right to question the integrity of a service, simply stating that "if you think its rigged dont play" really is very dismissive of many peoples genuine concern.  In any other retail industry if people thought they were being dealt with wrongly they would retain the right to question and complain, not just told "if you dont like it, dont shop there".  Frankly this attitude is a large part of the problem.  Have you ever tried to reach many of the online sites on a one to one basis?

    Lastly, alot of easy answers are put up in this blog.  I'd like to put up some counter arguments.  I'm not saying these are things I essentialy believe, but they do offer a counter point of view to the statements offered.

    You comment that there would be no winning players in that scenario.  In fact the opposite would be far more likely.  Surely the likes of Tom Dwan, Shwartz and Friedman would be the perfect PR poster boys of online poker sites?  Creating huge appeal, showing how young 20 somethings quickly become huge stars and Millionaires.

    Large faceless corporations have ALWAYS took advantage of their customers.  We live in a very mistrustful age, so despite opinions being hugely varied why do people find it so impossible that another amoral corporation could potentialy act in a less than honest way?  Conspiracy theories only remain so until they, quite often, end up being proven.  There is rarely smoke without fire.

    Again, I am not saying I believe these things, nor do i essentially believe online poker is rigged.  I guess what I'm really trying to say is that the debate isnt as simple and "nonsensical" as you propose, and laying it out your way kind of demeans and disregards all the peoples perspective that you open your blog with.  Who is anyone to say that they are assuredly correct?

    I see online as a very different game to live.  The skill level is much lower, people chase where they likely wouldnt live and people have access to cheap games that they frankly dont care enough about to play well, go bust and quickly play another one.  There's no chip handling and clicking a button makes for much looser aggressive play.  For me these elements play a big part in the action seen. 

    But there is much more to the debate here.
  • pod1pod1 Member Posts: 4,377
    edited February 2011
    nice post amybr, well written , like elsa and yourself say, its not down to doubters to prove its fixed, its down to the companys to prove WITH OUT A DOUBT that it isnt!!
  • elsadogelsadog Member Posts: 5,677
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Re: Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    nice post amybr, well written , like elsa and yourself say, its not down to doubters to prove its fixed, its down to the companys to prove WITH OUT A DOUBT that it isnt!!
    Posted by pod1
    They won't because they can't.

    A huge Corporation wishes to start a Poker Room that is above reproach then chooses to have the site regulated by an autonomous off-shore fiefdom rather than come under mainland UK regulation. If you ask legitimate questions about how the cards are distributed to the players all you are met with is waffle and silence.

    You can believe it if you like, refuse to ask questions and remain in the dark. It's your right and your choice. Just as it is the right of anyone who is undecided and therefore chooses to ask those awkward questions.
  • debdobs_67debdobs_67 Member Posts: 3,615
    edited February 2011
    Some good replys here including from at least 1 very very experienced and successful player (elsa).

    I for one find it kinda strange that a player of simuk's stature would post a blog on this subject.

    Most people who feel strongly on this matter,either for or against online poker being fixed in some form or other nearly always voice their opinion when these threads arise.

    Cant ever remember simuk posting on this matter at all.so why now?

    OR was he asked to make this blog?
  • stienstien Member Posts: 332
    edited February 2011
    As I said if there is nothing to hide get it authenticated by a well know reputable company, Deloitte's or KPMG would carry more weight than xxx we've never heard of.
  • loonytoonsloonytoons Member Posts: 4,270
    edited February 2011

    No one says that the site is rigged, what they are saying is the rng maybe isn't very random! However that doesn't mean you dont have to play, it just means that outdraws occur more often, and that can close the gap between the good and poor players, i should know ive donked a few quid off some good players, fish rule!!!!

  • LOL_RAISELOL_RAISE Member Posts: 2,188
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Re: Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    The skill level is much lower, people chase where they likely wouldnt live and people have access to cheap games that they frankly dont care enough about to play well, go bust and quickly play another one. 
    Posted by AMYBR

    if theres one difference between live and online play its that online is alot harder than live poker at the same levels
  • jakallyjakally Member Posts: 421
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Re: Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    I make a pretty decent living at Live Poker, mainly playing in the North East Casino's and DTD.  But Online I have had the utter worst swings.  
    Posted by AMYBR

    +1 to LoL_Raise's ccomment about online poker being, on average, much tougher than online... and it's not even close.

    Therefore it's not a surprise that ssomeone who is winning live, is less successful online.

    That's not intended to belittle the fact that you are making a living playing live poker... still need to be at a decent skill level... WP & long may it continue.


  • jakallyjakally Member Posts: 421
    edited February 2011
    In Response to Re: Is online poker rigged? - Blog Post:
    You comment that there would be no winning players in that scenario.  In fact the opposite would be far more likely.  Surely the likes of Tom Dwan, Shwartz and Friedman would be the perfect PR poster boys of online poker sites?  Creating huge appeal, showing how young 20 somethings quickly become huge stars and Millionaires. Large faceless corporations have ALWAYS took advantage of their customers.  
    Posted by AMYBR
    Given the huge downswings that at least 2 of these have had, it's stretching credibility to  suggest that, their success is in any way related to poker sites skewing things unfairly in their favour.

Sign In or Register to comment.